One More Perspective

There are as many realities as the number of people involved. – Hubay Vica


//

I am glad you are here. If this is the first time you are visiting this site, the following is a quick orientation. To read a single-perspective account of a Family’s complicated history from old Hungary to the highly-nuanced United States, please look for chapter numbering (zero to nine); the chapters build on one-another in numerical order. No chapter is meant to be a standalone one. There are also titles without a chapter designation; those are short writings about a broad range of seemingly random topics. Thank You for arriving with lovingkindness.

//

You Made Me Live Without You, and It Turns Out I Can

For a number of days now, a single sentence has been circulating in my head, refusing to let go:  “You made me live without you, and it turns out I can.” 

At first, I felt a flash of alarm when accounting for those to whom my brain was referring, and I concluded it’s a broad amalgam of people from my childhood to the present day. It started after a small, unexpected moment of relational whiplash with a friend last weekend, the kind where someone invites me onto a limb by complaining about a third party, and the second I step out onto that limb to agree with them, they do a sudden 180 and saw the limb off. They reclaim their halo as the calm, nice person, the defender, leaving me standing out in the cold looking like the harsh voice of judgement, the asshole.

My therapist this week gave me the cleanest filter for this:  true vulnerability is when people talk about themselves, not other people. True vulnerability is always a first-person (I) statement, while performative or defensive vulnerability is externalized (They or It). When someone complains to me about someone else, expresses exhaustion about their schedule, or vents about how they were wronged, it feels like intimacy because they are letting me behind the curtain of their composed public persona. …but they are not letting me into their heart; they are just outsourcing their irritation for five minutes. There is no risk to their ego in a third-party complaint, but there is ample work and risk for me.

As someone who has always been hungry for real depth and unvarnished honesty, I have spent years getting duped by that decoy. I see someone crack their shell an inch to vent, and I rush in with all eight arms of my loyalty and observation, mistaking a complaint for an invitation to bond. I hear a complaint and think “Finally, we are dropping the polite facade and talking about real things!” What I needed to learn is that if a story casts the speaker as the patient saint, the tired victim, or the reasonable person surrounded by difficult people, I am actually looking at armor, not skin.

When someone hands me that third-party complaint decoy, they are not asking for perspective, problem-solving or partnership. They are asking to be momentarily soothed so they can go back to feeling calm and sweet. When I step in with 100 percent clarity to validate the pattern they just handed me, I accidentally hold up a mirror. To someone who only wanted to let out five percent of their steam, my solidarity feels terrifyingly exposed, so they slam the vault door shut and instinctively reject my offer of connection.

Why did I keep falling for performative closeness and accepting friendship crumbs? Why did I keep cushioning other people’s guilt when they dropped the ball, telling them I don’t feel ignored when they vanished for weeks, or letting anxious friends use me to soothe their gut feelings from the driver’s seat of their lives while giving me nothing real in return? …because I was starving. Why was I starving? …because I had thrown away huge pieces of my own life out of societal shame. When a marriage ends and relationships with adult children fracture, the cultural script tells a woman, and especially a Mother, that her only moral posture is to stay in a crushing vacuum forever. Toxic. Narcissist. Estranged. If the ending was messy, you are supposed to treat the whole history as unmentionable.

For a long time, I exiled so many of my own memories into the dark because I was ashamed of how things broke, or ashamed of my own shadow’s participation in the breaking. I was also pushing my personal history to the cellar to gain love and acceptance from the very people, beginning with my parents, who were complicit in me being sexually abused by two different family members. When you discard your own past because of how the chapters ended, you hollow yourself out. You walk around with an empty chest, desperate for anyone else’s warmth to fill the cavity. That is where I was handing the people who withhold themselves their leverage.

Whether it is a family member, a former spouse or friends who ration their energy behind rigid walls, withholding carries an unspoken threat:  If I pull back my warmth, you will starve, and you will work twice as hard to bridge the gap. …and boy, did I!

The silent treatment is abuse. It means using another person’s desire for intimacy or answers as leverage against them, withholding these things to cause them pain.  Carolyn Hax, The Washington Post

If the outspoken one is doing the heavy lifting of self-containment in an effort to create less stimulus for the other, and the other person is using that space not to regulate themselves and return to the conversation, but to evade and reset, the relationship is entirely asymmetrical. A lack of capacity, when chronically unaddressed and weaponized as a default state over years, functions identically to calculated abuse. The intent behind the void matters far less than the fact that the one who is upset but containing it awaiting for a resolution together, is left alone to manage the entirety of the situation’s impact and the relationship’s deficits.

When it comes to my Mother and my spouses, it took me years of their withholding and my consequent over-functioning to wear myself out and earn the asshole branding.

…but by forcing me to live without their genuine love and care, actual vulnerability and reciprocity, they inadvertently put me through strength training. In that quiet space they left behind, I stopped waiting for their next need of me and went back to collect the pieces of myself I had exiled. I had stuffed my own life out of sight partly for my own shame of having failed at choosing people capable of and with capacity for genuine, equitable connection, but most of it for societal optics in favor of the comfort of a new spouse. 

This year however, one by one, I started bringing my shame-discarded memories back into my own light. I realized I do not have to throw away the joy, the excitement, the sweetness, the grit, the love, or the triumphs of my fifty-two years just because certain relationships, in fact foundational ones, had crashed. I do not need anyone else’s permission to keep my own history. When I let all of those exiled chapters back into the room, the whole picture came together, and it filled me right up from the inside. …because in hindsight across decades, it is practically impossible to separate the good from the bad. Both were necessary for revolution to occur. Who the fuck knew this was what I needed to do all along? …to own every last bit of what I am the culmination of, the good, the bad, the ugly. It’s the opposite of my childhood survival programming which required me to swallow every hurt and transgression and to put on a happy face; that kept me alive as a child but hollowed me out as an adult, and set me up as a relational time-bomb. Inviting the cracked and the misfired pottery to sit next to my perfectly symmetrical and shiny ones, then looking at all with humility and acceptance is the path to feeling whole and the actual transcending of generational emotional inheritance.

Looking across the full span of what I have built, survived, loved, and carried across a dozen different chapters of life, I am genuinely in awe of my lived experiences. I have had a massive, rich, full-contact life. I have no desire to polish, glue with gold or turn to a prettier angle the unattractive pottery of my life, whether handed to me or made by me. The entirety of it reflects my infinite tapestry back to me.

Once you are full of your own life, your palate changes overnight. You stop thanking people for handing you an empty plate. You see the metering at work, their scarcity. You no longer feel the pull to chase pebbles tossed at your window or to reply in earnest to canned text messages sent to you every few weeks.

With the holidays approaching, especially Christmas, the most performative of them all, the crushing vacuum that used to terrify me is simply gone. In fact, I am looking forward to not performing for anyone, but crafting the exact down-days, adventure days and learning days I want to have. I will buy no presents.

There is no malice in this realization, only a quiet, settled relief. You made me live without you. Turns out the absence of your rationed warmth forced me to reclaim every piece of my own story. 

Turns out, I’m grateful for it all. 

🎶 Summer went away
Still the yearning stays
I play it cool with the best of them
I wait patiently
He’s gonna notice me
It’s okay, we’re the best of friends
Anyway

I hear it in your voice
You’re smoking with your boys
I touch my phone as if it’s your face
I didn’t choose this town
I dream of getting out
There’s just one who could make me stay
All my days

I hear it in your voice
You’re smoking with your boys
I touch my phone as if it’s your face
I didn’t choose this town
I dream of getting out
There’s just one who could make me stay
All my days

From sprinkler splashes to fireplace ashes
I waited ages to see you there
I search the party of better bodies
Just to learn that you never cared
You’re on your own, kid
You always have been

I see the great escape
So long, Daisy May
I picked the petals, he loves me not
Something different bloomed
Writing in my room
I play my songs in the parking lot
I’ll run away

From sprinkler splashes to fireplace ashes
I called a taxi to take me there
I search the party of better bodies
Just to learn that my dreams aren’t rare
You’re on your own, kid
You always have been

From sprinkler splashes to fireplace ashes
I gave my blood, sweat, and tears for this
I hosted parties and starved my body

Like I’d be saved by a perfect kiss
The jokes weren’t funny, I took the money
My friends from home don’t know what to say

I looked around in a blood-soaked gown
And I saw something they can’t take away
‘Cause there were pages turned with the bridges burned
Everything you lose is a step you take
So make the friendship bracelets, take the moment and taste it
You’ve got no reason to be afraid

You’re on your own, kid
Yeah, you can face this
You’re on your own, kid
You always have been

Taylor Swift ‘You’re on Your Own, Kid’



Leave a Reply